After reading the memoir Yoga from the Inside Out by Christina
Sell, I have very mixed feelings about a lot what is said. Before I go in depth on my feelings about the
book, I must preference this. I have
limited exposure to both yoga and more importantly, the deeper philosophy of
yoga. I also have a very unique
perspective on both the so called “sleeping world”, which I will get into later
as well, but also the relationship of God, spirituality and the divine as well
because while I consider myself having a spiritual walk with God, I am again no
means an expert or well learned in that aspect either.
To begin, I did enjoy reading the memoir
and the overall message I received from it.
The idea that people today are too involved in what Ms. Sell calls the “sleeping
world.” This sleeping world, at least to
what I understood it as, is people buying into the society’s view of what is
acceptable, right, good, beautiful, fill in the blank with any adjective and
you have the idea. I do think that
people and society as a whole has adopted a unrealistic image of beauty. Not
only has the image of beauty been set at a bar that is impossible to reach by
many, the pressure to reach that goal also carries an unbearable weight
sometimes. I personally feel that
weight, as I am sure many other men do.
Take a look in any men’s fitness magazine or blockbuster movie. The guys all have extremely well defined
muscles all over; abs, back, arms, pecs.
Not only is that what is paraded around what a man should look like, but
it is also shown as what is needed to be successful in most aspects of
life. Those men typically are very
wealthy, have wives or girlfriends who also are the epitome of the definition
of beauty for the sleeping world. Do I
feel that is right to be set as the standard? No, but I also don’t think that
it is entirely wrong. The image of well
defined muscles and being lean is more than just something that is purely aesthetic. It also shows fitness and overall
health. To have that type of physique,
you have to be in shape and be in good shape.
This means you are taking care of your body by working out, being
careful about what you fuel your body with, etc. Even more with my profession,
staying in a good, healthy state is imperative. Personally, wanting to
subscribe to those standards of the sleeping world, is not bad because it
simply means I am in better shape and more capable of performing my job. Should it be taken to the extreme of eating
disorders and such no because then it becomes something that is unhealthy and
harmful, but wanting that goal and striving for it, I don’t see anything wrong
with that at all.
The other major problem I have is more philosophical
and religious in nature. Even after all
the discussion in class over the sutras, and reading quite a bit about yoga and
the philosophy, I am struggling to see how it is not a religion by itself. At
least in the way it is practiced and discussed in a lot of contemporary literature. All of the talk of the divine and spiritual
and the way you need a guru to interact with it and to show you the path has a
awkward juxtaposition with my personal faith background. It seems like it has quite a few places that any
religion, including Christianity, can fit in and work side by side with
yoga. Many of the core values are the
same, but there is a disconnect still that is hard for me to explain, much less
put into words. The easiest way I can
break it down is how the first yoga teacher, if you can call her that,
explained it to me. Mary Francis is a
very good friend of my mothers, and our families are close. Mary Francis has become a yoga instructor
after starting yoga herself and teaches restorative yoga. For various reasons
my mom began going to take yoga from Mary Francis and dragged me along one time
I was home. The way that Mary Francis
told me, was to incorporate yoga into your faith, not your faith into yoga. It
just seems that so much faith is worked into yoga. At least that is the way it
is portrayed. Something about that bugs
me, and I don’t have a good explanation why.
If I ever figure it you, if anyone ever reads this blog, yall will be
the first to know.
I do agree with you about the yoga being somewhat of a religion. In my own practice (this is just one student to another) I've been reading everything keeping in mind that I am a Christian and that all of it doesn't have to apply to me. i don't have to agree with all the sutras. I know most people look at yoga as some form of religion (or at least that's how I'm viewing it), but just keep in mind that you don't have to agree with everything they say! You are awesome! see you in class!
ReplyDelete